Based on the Restaurantji rankings, here are the **best pizza restaurants in New Lenox, IL**: | Rank | Restaurant | Rating | Reviews | |------|-----------|--------|---------| | 1 | **Pizza Di Farfalla** | ⭐ 4.8 Superb | 142 reviews | | 2 | **Paisano's Restaurant** | ⭐ 4.7 Superb | 78 reviews | | 3 | **Sbarro New Lenox** | ⭐ 4.6 Superb | 19 reviews | | 4 | **Pizza Mia! New Lenox** | ⭐ 4.4 Superb | 99 reviews | | 5 | **Nancy's Pizza New Lenox** | ⭐ 4.4 Superb | 43 reviews | | 6 | **Beggars Pizza - New Lenox** | ⭐ 4.2 Good | 112 reviews | | 7 | **Rosati's Pizza** | ⭐ 4.2 Good | 84 reviews | | 8 | **Lou Malnati's Pizzeria** | ⭐ 4.1 Good | 100 reviews | | 9 | **Joey's Red Hots** | ⭐ 4.1 Good | 182 reviews | | 10 | **Aurelio's Pizza of New Lenox** | ⭐ 3.8 Good | 71 reviews | | 11 | **Italian Fiesta Pizzeria** | ⭐ 3.7 Good | 114 reviews | **Top picks:** - **Pizza Di Farfalla** (4.8/5) — 1333 S Schoolhouse Rd. Highest rated, with favorites including Nonna's Sausage & Giardiniera pizza, Pepperoni Cups, and Garlic Rolls. - **Paisano's Restaurant** (4.7/5) — 350 W Maple St. Full Italian restaurant known for huge portions and great value. - **Pizza Mia! New Lenox** (4.4/5) — 830 W Laraway Rd. Famous for thin crust and Italian beef pizza. - **Nancy's Pizza** (4.4/5) — 1840 E Lincoln Hwy. Chicago-style pizza specialist. - **Beggars Pizza** (4.2/5) — 650 W Maple St. Local favorite worth the trip, great thin crust.